I'm a huge fan of the Harry Potter books (and I specify books because the movies are an insult to Rowling's genius). While reading the Chamber of Secrets a couple of months back, I came across an interesting theme when Dumbledore tells Harry 'it is our choices, Harry, that show what we truly are, far more than our abilities.'
This single line got my thinking, about choices, about free will, and about identity (yet again).
I do not believe in 'destiny'. I don't believe that God (yes I do believe in Him) put us on Earth with our whole existence written down for us, we being mere puppets enacting a script written in stone. Man was created (or evolved, whichever you prefer) with a free will, the master of his own decisions. Granted, circumstances are often out of our control, but how we react to them isn't, and that is what shows our true mettle. Our reactions are also, ironically, what alter the circumstances in the future, hence being what shapes our lives and determines our 'destiny'. (And in following this theory, the circumstances we find difficult to face are mostly the result of our own doings).
Choices are complicated things. Everyday is filled with a hundred little decisions to be made, whether they are trivial or otherwise. Sometimes, the decisions we have to make are difficult, like choosing between the blurry lines of right and wrong, or the easier and the more difficult, or following the well-travelled path or making a completely new road for yourself. Yet the right thing may be the most difficult to do, or breaking away from expectations (and tradition) to 'follow your heart' the right AND the more difficult. Brings to mind a couple of lines written by Robert Frost,
'Two roads diverged in a wood, and I -
I took the one less travelled by,
And that has made all the difference.'
So ultimately, who we are comes down to not the labels we are born with or have thrust upon us along the way, but rather the choices we make in our lives. I have made a lot of terrible decisions in my life, but I do not regret my mistakes, because I learned from them. They made me who I am today.
I am proud of who I am today.
Showing posts with label identity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label identity. Show all posts
Sunday, February 1, 2009
Wednesday, January 7, 2009
Falling Leaves...
...Return To Their Roots
When I was in the 8th grade, I was moved by my Literature book, Chinese Cinderella, by Adeline Yen Mah. A story of downright vindictiveness suffered by a child at the hands of her family, my eyes were opened to a culture and suffering that had been non-existent to me. I knew the author had written one more book, aimed at a more mature audience, but never got down to reading it. Finally, after 6 years, I read Falling Leaves yesterday.
The book made me think of my roots, and once again reminded me of something I've been struggling with for quite some time. I don't know where I belong. While I love Melbourne, I cannot help but feel alienated.
I never felt this way in Dubai, where racism was rampant and often ill-disguised. Ironically, I hated the city and could not wait to get out of it, but I felt comfortable there, and took the feeling of belonging for granted. That being said, I doubt I will ever return there, for life here is generally much more comfortable, relaxed. What I have here, I could never even hope to have in Dubai - peace of mind.
Pakistan, then again, is something else altogether. I have barely ever been there, and if I feel 'almost alien' here, I might as well have been from a completely different galaxy, time AND dimension when in Pakistan.
I suppose I'm just at that stage in your life (and have been for some time) where your need to search for answers intensifies, answers to your reason for being, your place in the world, your spirituality... I'm on my search for identity, though I'm no closer to finding it than I was before. I guess this is something you have to get used to when you come from a minority in every sense of the word - Pakistani, Christian, gay - an almost hypothetical combination.
Falling leaves return to their roots.
But sometimes new roots have to be put down in a new place for the leaves to return to.
When I was in the 8th grade, I was moved by my Literature book, Chinese Cinderella, by Adeline Yen Mah. A story of downright vindictiveness suffered by a child at the hands of her family, my eyes were opened to a culture and suffering that had been non-existent to me. I knew the author had written one more book, aimed at a more mature audience, but never got down to reading it. Finally, after 6 years, I read Falling Leaves yesterday.
The book made me think of my roots, and once again reminded me of something I've been struggling with for quite some time. I don't know where I belong. While I love Melbourne, I cannot help but feel alienated.
I never felt this way in Dubai, where racism was rampant and often ill-disguised. Ironically, I hated the city and could not wait to get out of it, but I felt comfortable there, and took the feeling of belonging for granted. That being said, I doubt I will ever return there, for life here is generally much more comfortable, relaxed. What I have here, I could never even hope to have in Dubai - peace of mind.
Pakistan, then again, is something else altogether. I have barely ever been there, and if I feel 'almost alien' here, I might as well have been from a completely different galaxy, time AND dimension when in Pakistan.
I suppose I'm just at that stage in your life (and have been for some time) where your need to search for answers intensifies, answers to your reason for being, your place in the world, your spirituality... I'm on my search for identity, though I'm no closer to finding it than I was before. I guess this is something you have to get used to when you come from a minority in every sense of the word - Pakistani, Christian, gay - an almost hypothetical combination.
Falling leaves return to their roots.
But sometimes new roots have to be put down in a new place for the leaves to return to.
Saturday, December 6, 2008
On Identity
I'm gay. There, I said it. I've known it all along, and except for a brief period of awkward uncertainty, I've come to love this aspect of myself... despite people's preconceived misconceptions about me based on this single fact. I wouldn't say I'm closeted - I'm out to all my friends, a hell lot of not-my-friends-but-acquaintances, and part of my family (though I'm pretty sure the other half is convinced of the truth, or at least suspicious about it). I know who I am, and I'm proud of it.
I don't, however, know how to identify myself to others. Yes, I'm gay; but I'm also a Christian, which goes against being gay. To complicate things further, I'm also Pakistani, which goes against my being BOTH, gay AND Christian! So arises my dilemma - I know who I am, but what do I tell others who I am? My sexuality goes against my race and religion - theoretically, I should be beheaded (or at least stoned to death) and be burning in the eternal fires of hell right now! Or so I'm told, at least.
Speaking of fire, let's add fuel to it. I suffer from regular bouts of depression and loneliness, which many brand "emo". Yet at the same time, I'm supposedly a "social butterfly". I'm a narcissist who's known to have self-image problems, a writer with writer's block and one-dimensional-thinking, a very intelligent person who's known to be terribly naive and has made some of the worst decisions, a singer with limited musical talent, an academic genius who's physically incapable of doing any "real work"... And on and on it goes.
So you see? I'm a lot of words. It's only understandable then that I get confused in my search for identity, and am always at a loss for words when someone asks me to tell them something about myself. It's in those few silent, awkward moments that all these words shoot through my head like a meteor shower, and I' m ultimately inevitably dumbfounded, and at a loss for words (which really is surprising as I seem to have accumulated a whole bank of words over the years!)
I hope one day I will be able to answer the more important question; who am i? It's only myself I am answerable to, and the correct answer to this question would be everything above, and none of it. For everything I wrote here is true, no matter how paradoxical it may seem - all my flaws, my strengths, and things that are neither, but just are, they're all part of me. And that's exactly what they are, part of me (keyword being "part")!
I don't let myself get branded by one particular label, because it's not just that label that defines me. Yes, I may be gay, but I'm also a thousand other things. Preconceived misconceptions based on, say my sexuality, are therefore unjustified. My gay gene, if there indeed is such a thing, makes up only a tiny percentage of my genome after all.
And while I may be no closer to finding the answer to that ever-impending and equally perplexing question, I take solace in the fact that I am me.
And that no one is, or ever can be.
I don't, however, know how to identify myself to others. Yes, I'm gay; but I'm also a Christian, which goes against being gay. To complicate things further, I'm also Pakistani, which goes against my being BOTH, gay AND Christian! So arises my dilemma - I know who I am, but what do I tell others who I am? My sexuality goes against my race and religion - theoretically, I should be beheaded (or at least stoned to death) and be burning in the eternal fires of hell right now! Or so I'm told, at least.
Speaking of fire, let's add fuel to it. I suffer from regular bouts of depression and loneliness, which many brand "emo". Yet at the same time, I'm supposedly a "social butterfly". I'm a narcissist who's known to have self-image problems, a writer with writer's block and one-dimensional-thinking, a very intelligent person who's known to be terribly naive and has made some of the worst decisions, a singer with limited musical talent, an academic genius who's physically incapable of doing any "real work"... And on and on it goes.
So you see? I'm a lot of words. It's only understandable then that I get confused in my search for identity, and am always at a loss for words when someone asks me to tell them something about myself. It's in those few silent, awkward moments that all these words shoot through my head like a meteor shower, and I' m ultimately inevitably dumbfounded, and at a loss for words (which really is surprising as I seem to have accumulated a whole bank of words over the years!)
I hope one day I will be able to answer the more important question; who am i? It's only myself I am answerable to, and the correct answer to this question would be everything above, and none of it. For everything I wrote here is true, no matter how paradoxical it may seem - all my flaws, my strengths, and things that are neither, but just are, they're all part of me. And that's exactly what they are, part of me (keyword being "part")!
I don't let myself get branded by one particular label, because it's not just that label that defines me. Yes, I may be gay, but I'm also a thousand other things. Preconceived misconceptions based on, say my sexuality, are therefore unjustified. My gay gene, if there indeed is such a thing, makes up only a tiny percentage of my genome after all.
And while I may be no closer to finding the answer to that ever-impending and equally perplexing question, I take solace in the fact that I am me.
And that no one is, or ever can be.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
